Start with The World According to Garp. It is 568 pages and none of them are hard, and it contains the whole machine in one book: comedy running headlong into catastrophe, usually in the same paragraph, and a writer's life told at full length. Read A Prayer for Owen Meany second, with a few days in between, because both endings need time to settle.
The alternative most often suggested is to reverse those two, and it is a reasonable case — A Prayer for Owen Meany is the more emotional and the more tightly engineered book, and it converts more readers than anything else he wrote. Take The World According to Garp first anyway. It teaches you the Under Toad, a child's mishearing of undertow turned into a name for the dread that something is coming, and that one concept is the most useful thing you can carry into the other ten books.
Say this before page one. Irving's novels contain a great deal of sex and sudden, graphic violence that arrives without warning in the middle of comic scenes. Readers who come to him from the films are routinely blindsided, because the adaptations soften or remove most of it. The World According to Garp in particular contains a sexual accident played for horror, farce and grief at once.
The recurring furniture is not a limitation
New England boarding schools, wrestling, Vienna, bears, absent or dead parents, writers as protagonists, prostitutes, sudden fatal accidents. Irving reuses them the way a composer reuses a key. Once you notice, you are reading him correctly rather than catching him out.
The core: the big mid-career novels
The CIDER HOUSE RULES, The Hotel New Hampshire, A Widow for One Year. Eight or nine weeks for 1,640 pages. The CIDER HOUSE RULES is his one thesis novel — an orphanage doctor in Maine who delivers babies and performs illegal abortions, arguing a position through practice rather than speeches — and it is a deliberate Dickens pastiche, which explains its coincidences and its enormous cast; its migrant-workers section contains an incest subplot that arrives with no warning. The Hotel New Hampshire is the strangest of the famous four and the most extreme in content, with a gang rape and its long aftermath and an incestuous relationship between two siblings, neither played for shock. Its phrase for not killing yourself, keep passing the open windows, is the clearest statement of the Irving worldview. A Widow for One Year is the best-written of the three and comes in three widely separated parts; break between them rather than pushing through.
The early books, once you are committed
Setting free the bears, The water-method man, The 158-pound marriage. These are the raw materials — everything the famous novels do at 600 pages is here in cruder form at 300 — and reading them after the big four is far more rewarding than reading them first. The debt to Günter Grass is open and acknowledged, and the Vienna obsession is born in the first novel and never leaves. The water-method man is his funniest and most formally playful book. The 158-pound marriage is the lean, cold outlier, modelled on the European novel of adultery, and Irving has called it his least characteristic; read last of the three, it shows you what he later chose not to be.
The completist tail: late Irving
Until I Find You is 848 pages, the longest thing he wrote, and the most divisive novel of his career: its childhood section contains sustained sexual abuse of a young boy by adult women, presented in a register many readers find unbearable and some find dishonest about what it depicts. That is the substance of the divide, and it is better known before page one than discovered at page two hundred. Set a fixed daily page target, and take a break afterwards rather than pushing on. Last Night in Twisted River is the better-shaped of the two long late books and is openly about Irving's own method. In One Person closes the path with all the oldest furniture repurposed for a bisexual narrator's life from the 1950s through the AIDS years, and its grief sections are the one place where the machine is switched off.
Where to stop
After the first two is a complete experience and most readers stop there. After the mid-career three you have the whole method. Go further only if the pattern itself has become the interest. More single-author routes are on Discover.
Follow the full ordered path here: Best John Irving Books, in Reading Order.
Ready to learn something deeply?
Build a reading path — free
