Alexandre Dumas Reading Order: Where to Start
Dumas published something like a hundred volumes, much of it with collaborators, so completeness is not a sensible goal and nobody sane attempts it. What a reading order can do is settle two questions: which of the two famous novels to open with, and how the d'Artagnan sequence actually breaks up, since its final instalment is a single enormous French novel that English publishers chop into three or four separately titled books. Start with one great standalone, take the musketeer cycle as a unit, then choose among the other historical romances.
Start Here: The Two Famous Ones
BeginnerRead the two novels everyone means by Dumas, and decide which kind of Dumas reader you are — the adventure serial or the revenge epic.
▸ Study plan for this stage
Pace: 6-7 weeks, but check what you are buying before you start the clock. An unabridged The Three Musketeers runs to around 700 pages and an unabridged Count of Monte Cristo comfortably past 1,000, so budget about three weeks and four at 40 pages a day. Our catalogue entries here are records of particula
- Everything on this path is translated, and Dumas translations vary more than most: some are complete, many are Victorian versions still in print because they are out of copyright, and the cover almost never tells you which you have
- The word adaptation on a title page means a rewrite, usually for schools or children, not a translation. Two entries on this path carry that word, and neither is the book you actually want to read
- The Three Musketeers was a newspaper serial paid by the instalment. The cliffhanger chapter endings, the padding and the sheer number of scenes in taverns are the economics of that arrangement showing through the prose
- The Count of Monte Cristo spends roughly its first third building a machine and the rest running it. Abridgements cut the building, which is why readers of cut editions remember the escape and the treasure but not the cost
- Milady is the real antagonist of The Three Musketeers and its most modern character; every screen version shrinks her, so the novel will surprise you
- D'Artagnan is nineteen and the book knows it. The comedy only works if you do not mistake him for a hero yet
- The two novels are unconnected. Choosing between them is a question of what you want first — the serial adventure with three sequels behind it, or the single self-contained epic
- Which edition are you actually holding — how many pages, how many chapters, and does it name a translator anywhere?
- The Three Musketeers begins as a run of escapades. Where does it stop being episodes and become a plot with a shape?
- What does Dantes lose during the years the revenge takes to build, and where does the novel first let you see the cost?
- Milady is destroyed by something the novel presents as justice. Is it, and does Dumas believe it is?
- One of these two books wants you to admire its hero and one is testing you. Which is which, and how early can you tell?
- Before you commit, turn to the last page and read the number. An unabridged Three Musketeers is roughly 700 pages and an unabridged Monte Cristo over 1,000; anything far under that has been cut, whatever the cover says.
- Count the chapters in your Monte Cristo against a complete edition's contents list. The full novel runs to 117 chapters, and a short count is the fastest abridgement test there is.
- Look for the translator's name on the copyright page. If there is none, you are almost certainly reading a nineteenth-century public-domain text rather than a modern translation.
- Mark the page in Monte Cristo where you first stop rooting for Dantes. Later, compare it with where the novel itself seems to think that page is.
Next up: Now take the musketeers as a cycle, which in English means learning that four novels are sold as six or seven separate books.
![The three musketeers [adaptation]](https://covers.openlibrary.org/b/id/14564075-M.jpg)
The better first book if you want the sequence: fast, funny, episodic, and it introduces the four characters you will follow across three more novels. Be warned that d'Artagnan is nineteen and behaves like it, and that Milady is far darker than any screen version.
![The Count of Monte-Cristo [3/5]](https://covers.openlibrary.org/b/id/14557288-M.jpg)
The better first book if you only ever read one. A wrongful imprisonment, an escape, a fortune and a decade of methodical revenge, sustained across a very long novel without slackening. Read an unabridged edition; the popular abridgements cut the middle third, which is where the moral cost accumulates.
The d'Artagnan Romances, in Order
IntermediateFollow the four musketeers from youth to old age in publication order, and learn how the final volume is divided in English.
▸ Study plan for this stage
Pace: 8-10 weeks, and this is the long haul of the path. Twenty Years After runs to around 800 pages unabridged, and the three entries after it are all parts of one enormous novel — the volumes in our catalogue are 587 and 564 pages, with a third part beyond them. At 40 pages a day that is two and a half
- The cycle is three novels, not six. The Three Musketeers, then Twenty Years After, then Le Vicomte de Bragelonne — and the third is so long that English publishers cut it into two, three or four separately titled books
- The last three entries in this stage — The Vicomte de Bragelonne, Louise de la Valliere and The Man in the Iron Mask — are consecutive parts of that single novel. Reading them is reading one book; buying them is buying one book in pieces
- Which pieces you get depends entirely on the publisher. Some split at two volumes, some at three, some at four, and the same title can cover different amounts of text in different series, so two readers can own The Man in the Iron Mask and have read different quantities of Dumas
- The Man in the Iron Mask is the worst offender because it is marketed as a standalone. It is usually the final quarter or less of the novel and makes little sense on its own. The catalogue entry on this path is a 50-page adaptation, which is not the text you want
- Twenty Years After is the political novel of the cycle: the four are older, on opposing sides of the Fronde, and the friendship rather than the swordplay is what gets tested
- The Louise de la Valliere section is the slow one and is the part most often cut or skimmed. The ending is close to unintelligible without it, so read it rather than skipping ahead to the iron mask
- Dumas worked with Auguste Maquet, who drafted plots and scenes for these books. The by-line is Dumas alone, and the arrangement ended up in court in his lifetime
- Open each volume you own and read its first and last chapter headings. Do they run continuously into the next volume, or is there a gap where text should be?
- What has changed for the four between the first novel and Twenty Years After, and which of them has changed least?
- Athos spends the third novel being a father. What does the cycle gain by making its most romantic figure responsible for a son?
- Aramis in the final section does something the earlier books would not have permitted him. When did he become that man, and did you see it happening?
- The cycle ends in death and disappointment. Was it always going there, or does Dumas turn somewhere along the way?
- Before buying, add the page counts of the volumes you are holding and compare the total with a complete unabridged Vicomte de Bragelonne, which runs past two thousand pages in English. If your set totals half that, you have an abridgement.
- Write down the chapter number each volume ends on and the number the next one begins on. Publishers who split the novel carelessly leave a gap, and this is the only way to see it before you fall into it.
- Keep one page listing the four musketeers with their ages, ranks and allegiances at the start of each novel. The cycle spans decades and the shifts are easy to miss inside the scenes.
- When you reach the final section, go back and reread the scene in The Three Musketeers where the four first drink together. The ending is built to be measured against it.
Next up: With the cycle behind you, the other historical romances show the same machine pointed at different French catastrophes.
The direct sequel, and a genuinely better novel than its reputation suggests: the four are older, on opposite political sides, and the Fronde and the English Civil War pull them apart. Read it straight after The Three Musketeers.
The opening movement of the final, vast instalment. In French it is one book; in English it is usually split, and this is the first part. Expect court politics and the restoration of Charles II rather than swordplay.
The middle section of the same novel, given its own title in English: Louis XIV's court, and the romance that ruins Raoul. Slower than anything else in the cycle, and the part most readers skim — read it anyway, because the last section depends on it entirely.
![The man in the iron mask [adaptation]](https://covers.openlibrary.org/b/id/14566978-M.jpg)
The final section, and the reason to have read the other three thousand pages. The twin-king conspiracy, Aramis at his most ruthless, and the deaths of characters you met as young men. Never read it as a standalone, whatever the paperback cover implies.
The Other Historical Romances
IntermediateMove to the cycles Dumas set around the other great French crises, and see the same method applied to the Wars of Religion and the Terror.
▸ Study plan for this stage
Pace: 4-5 weeks. The Knight of Maison-Rouge is 423 pages and Queen Margot runs somewhat longer, though our catalogue records no page count for the edition we hold — plan on about three weeks for Margot and ten days for Maison-Rouge at 40 pages a day. Both are shorter than anything in the previous stage, w
- Older English translations sell Queen Margot as Marguerite de Valois. Same novel, different title, and searching for only one of the two will make you think it is out of print
- Queen Margot opens the Valois trilogy. The two that follow it are not on this path and are considerably harder to find in decent English editions, so treat this as a first volume you may not be able to complete
- The St Bartholomew's Day massacre arrives in the first stretch of the book rather than at the climax, because Dumas is interested in what people do in the weeks after an atrocity rather than in the atrocity itself
- The Valois books are colder than the musketeer cycle: poison, court faction and no consoling friendship to fall back on. This is the best evidence that Dumas could write political horror as well as swashbuckling
- The Knight of Maison-Rouge belongs to his Revolution novels and is short by his standards, which makes it the easiest of the later historical novels to actually finish
- Both books put invented protagonists alongside real documented figures. That is the standard Dumas machine, and it is exactly why his history is unreliable in the same measure that it is readable
- Margot was a real woman with a scandalous posthumous reputation. What does Dumas take from that reputation, and what does he decline to use?
- Where does the massacre sit in the structure of Queen Margot, and what does placing it early allow Dumas to do that a climax would not?
- The Knight of Maison-Rouge is a rescue novel whose historical outcome every reader already knows. How does Dumas keep it tense anyway?
- Compare Catherine de Medici here with Richelieu in The Three Musketeers. What kind of antagonist does Dumas actually enjoy writing?
- Which of these two would you give to a reader who loved Monte Cristo but bounced off The Three Musketeers, and why?
- Check the title page before you buy: if it says Marguerite de Valois, you are holding Queen Margot under its older English title, and you do not need both.
- List the characters in Queen Margot who existed and those who did not. The invented ones do most of the plot work, which tells you what the historical cast is for.
- Read the last twenty pages of The Knight of Maison-Rouge in one sitting. The book is built to be finished that way and loses most of its force if you stop partway.
Next up: Two short novels remain, and they show a Dumas the adventure reputation hides completely.
The first of the Valois romances, opening on the St Bartholomew's Day Massacre. Bloodier and more cynical than the musketeer books, and the best single demonstration that Dumas could do political horror as well as swashbuckling.
A conspiracy to rescue Marie Antoinette from the Temple prison, told from inside revolutionary Paris. Short by his standards and unusually tense, it is the easiest of the later historical novels to finish.
The Deeper Cuts
BeginnerFinish with two short novels that show a Dumas the adventure reputation hides, including the one that draws directly on his own family history.
▸ Study plan for this stage
Pace: 2-3 weeks, ~30 pages a day. The Black Tulip is 331 pages and Georges 336, so this is by far the shortest stage on the path — after the d'Artagnan cycle it will read like a holiday. Give each about a week and a half.
- The Black Tulip opens on a real lynching in 1672 and then becomes a prison romance about growing a flower. The tonal switch is deliberate and the first forty pages surprise almost every reader
- It is the tightest plot Dumas ever built, which is the best evidence that the sprawl elsewhere was a serial writer's choice rather than an inability to control a book
- The Black Tulip is a common school text, so cut classroom editions circulate widely. It is short enough that a suspiciously slim copy is the giveaway
- Georges is a revenge novel set on colonial Mauritius with a mixed-race protagonist, and its structure is close enough to Monte Cristo that it reads as the trial run for it
- Dumas was the grandson of an enslaved woman in Saint-Domingue and the son of a general born into slavery there. Georges is the one novel that engages that inheritance directly
- Georges appeared in 1843, the year before The Three Musketeers, and good English translations were scarce for a long time. Older editions carry Victorian cuts and softenings, so the edition question applies here too
- The Black Tulip spends its opening on political murder and the rest on horticulture. Is that one book or two, and does Dumas ever connect them?
- What does Georges do with race that Monte Cristo, written the following year, drops entirely?
- Georges and Dantes both return transformed and wealthy to punish the people who wronged them. Where do the two novels part company?
- Having read the cycle and the standalones, can you state the Dumas plot in one sentence that fits at least four of these books?
- Which book on this path was cut down by a publisher rather than by its author, and how would you have known without being told?
- Read the first forty pages of The Black Tulip, then write down what you expect the novel to be about. Keep the note; you will be wrong, and the wrongness is the pleasure.
- Set Georges beside the first two hundred pages of Monte Cristo and mark the structural beats they share. There are more than you expect, and they arrive in the same order.
- Go back through every book on this path and record which edition you actually read: translator, page count, complete or abridged. Whichever one you cannot answer for is the one to reread properly.
- Pick the Dumas you would give a friend and write the two-sentence case, naming the edition as well as the title. With this author the edition is half the recommendation.
Next up: You now know the whole shape of Dumas and, more usefully, how to tell a complete Dumas from a publisher's fragment of one before you buy it.
A miniature: Dutch tulip mania, a lynching, a prisoner and a flower. Barely two hundred pages, and the tightest plotting he ever managed, which makes it a useful corrective if the long novels have exhausted you.
A revenge novel about a mixed-race hero on colonial Mauritius, written by the grandson of an enslaved Haitian woman, and widely read as the trial run for Monte Cristo. Read it last: it is the book that makes you reconsider the ones you started with.
Discussion
Keep reading
Paths that share books, cover the same subject, or open a related topic.
